There isn’t much top-tier talent at running back in this year’s draft, but there are several intriguing players who could help the Bears fill a niche behind starter Matt Forte.
There’s a chance that no running backs are chosen on May 8 in the first round at a position that continues to be devalued as the NFL becomes more and more of a passing league. But there are a handful of role players and situational runners/receivers who can provide a change of pace or a pass-catching threat out of the backfield.
Name, school Ht. Wt. 40 Skinny
Carlos Hyde, Ohio St. 5-11.7 230 4.66 Near-unanimous choice as draft’s best all-around RB. Tough, powerful runner who lacks breakaway speed.
Bishop Sankey, Wash. 5-9.4 209 4.49 Has been a workhorse but lacks Hyde’s size and strength, although he provides more wiggle and quickness.
Dri Archer, Kent State 5-7.6 173 4.26 Legit take-it-to-the-house threat on every carry and catch. Ball security, durability are concerns.
Tre Mason, Auburn 5-8.4 207 4.50 Very good burst, instincts and vision but has a tendency to dance too much. Durability could be a concern.
Jeremy Hill, LSU 6-0.5 233 4.66 Has character concerns and lacks a top gear but is a tough, powerful runner with little wear and tear.
De’Anthony Thomas, Ore. 5-8.5 174 4.49 Big-play threat as runner-receiver. Plays faster than 40-time but is tiny and has prima donna concerns.
Charles Sims, West Va. 6-0.0 214 4.48 Good size/speed combo with very good acceleration but isn’t elusive. Provides excellent option in pass game.
Andre Williams, BC 5-11.3 230 4.56 Doesn’t possess much shake and bake but runs with purpose and piles up yards after contact.
Lache Seastrunk, Baylor 5-9.4 201 4.51 Nifty runner who relies too much on agility and too often dances instead of going north-south.
Ka’Deem Carey, Arizona 5-9.3 207 4.70 Character, lack of speed are negatives but productive workhorse carried 652 times for 3,814 yards in two years.
Note: Number following the period under “Ht.” refers to eighths of an inch.
Oregon’s De’Anthony Thomas and Kent State’s Dri (pronounced Dree) Archer are two of the most electrifying, although both come in extremely small packages. Thomas stands 5-foot-8⅝ and weighs 174. Archer is 5-7¾ 3/4 and weighs 173.
Neither player will ever be an every-down running back in the NFL, and both could project best to slot receiver because of their receiving skills. Thomas averaged 11.5 yards on 113 career receptions with the Ducks and scored 20 touchdowns.
Thomas grew up in South Central Los Angeles and got his start in the Snoop Dogg Youth Football League, where he also earned a nickname from the rap star.
“My first game against his team, we blew them out 52-0,” Thomas said. “That’s when he established the name ‘The Black Mamba.’ ”
According to Thomas, Snoop Dogg tagged him with the nickname before it was made more famous by Kobe Bryant.
“I feel like everyone knows I was (The Black Mamba) way before Kobe Bryant. It was my childhood days,” Thomas said. “He was just in the spotlight more than me. One day we could do a commercial about it or something.”
Even if Thomas is just an afterthought as a runner at the next level, he can still be an impact player. In addition to his pass catching, he averaged 17.1 yards on punt returns and scored 4 TDs on kickoff returns while averaging 25.8 yards.
Archer might be even more of a big-play threat than Thomas because of his elite speed that makes everyone else on the field appear to be running in sand.
Archer’s 4.26-second 40-yard dash was the fastest at this year’s Scouting Combine and just missed the all-time Combine record of 4.24 set by Titans running back Chris Johnson. Archer also brings more to the table than the potential to be a change of pace at running back.
Like Thomas he scored 4 kickoff return touchdowns, and he scored 12 more TDs on 99 career receptions.
To have success in the NFL, Thomas and Archer will have to go to teams that can devise creative ways to get them involved in the offense that utilize their unique talents. The Chiefs have had decent success utilizing Dexter McCluster’s skills since drafting him in the second round in 2010, even though he’s just 172 pounds.
In four seasons, McCluster has caught 172 passes for 1,500 yards (8.7-yard average) and rushed 152 times for 662 yards (4.4-yard average). Last year he averaged 11.8 yards on 58 punt returns while scoring twice, and he has handled kickoff-return duties in the past.
“Whenever you get those (little) guys, that 170-plus pounds, the question is how do you use them?” NFL Network’s Mike Mayock said. “Where do you line them up? How many touches can I get him per game?
“So you look at a kid like (Archer) and you go: Is he a fourth-round guy where he’s going to be a situation guy, slot (receiver), motion, hand him the ball?
“You look at McCluster, you look at (St. Louis Rams 176-pound receiver) Tavon Austin, and they’re still trying to figure out how to get those guys the ball consistently.”
A chance to be involved in an offense is all Thomas wants.
“I feel I can be successful (at running back),” he said. “Just put me on the field and let me make plays and contribute to the team.”